Is mama melrose the best restaurant at mgm?

[daftaboutdisney]

oops its not mgm now is it but is mama melrose better than the brown derby ?

[Dawn]

I would say no. I've eaten at the Brown Derby twice and had awesome food both times.

[Keith]

Harder for me. Mama Melrose has a new chef who really cares about his work BUT having said that we've had inconsistent experiences there :/

Problem is, since the dining plan, we've had inconsistent experiences at the Brown Derby too! Cold chicken which took three visits back to the kitchen with a none-too-pleased server to get luke warm. Seafood which I'm sure made me ill and servers who were nowhere to be found throughout the meal.

Hard one. I WOULD still go with the Brown Derby but it costs!

[Ursula]

I have always had good food at Prime Time.

[Keith]

I have always had good food at Prime Time.

I've never been because I'm a scaredy cat there's no way I'd get by without getting picked on is there?

[Johnie]

I really enjoy Mama Melrose. We've been several times. We've only been to Brown Derby once and it was good too.

[Britchick]

i've not been to either actually, prime time usually wins over- we don't tend to spend much time in this park anyway

[Ursula]

Not everyone gets picked on Keith. I've seen people who just want to eat and they get left alone. Think the servers can tell when you don't want it.

[Johnie]

You can always ask to get a more sedate server

[uscwest]

We haven't eaten at Mama Melrose in a long time. I love the Cobb Salad at the Brown Derby but I have only had one REALLY good meal there. IMHO they should close the Brown Derby (just like the real one is closed) and open up something else in that spot.