So my friends that just returned from Disney brought back the recipe for the 50's Prime Time Cafe PB&J Milkshake. We are getting together tomorrow afternoon to grill and we thought it might be fun to mix up a batch (and perhaps experiment w/ which alcohol mixes better with it ) Here's the recipe: * 4 ounce Peanut Butter * 4 Ounce Grape Jelly * 72 Ounces Vanilla Ice Cream * 8 Ounces Milk * 8 Ounces Pure Vanilla Extract Place flavoring in blender. Add milk. Add ice cream. Blend until smooth and thick. Pour into your favorite glass. Makes 4 Portions Now, my only problem with this recipe is that it calls for EIGHT ounces of vanilla extract. Do you know how expensive that stuff is!?!?! I just priced it at my local grocery store, and 2 four ounce bottles are $9.99 EACH! That's $20 worth of ingredients right there, and that's not even including the ice cream, peanut butter and other ingredients! WOW!