Oooh, the Beach Club is awesome! It reminds me of a seaside cottage, albeit quite a bit bigger! :D
The CMs there are really nice and go out of their way to help out. We love Cape May as everyone knows, and the pool is one of the nicest on property. It has so many different aspects that it has something for everyone.
It's the closest resort to the IG, so that makes it a winner in our book, hands down!
We love our OKW, for sure but the Beach Club was the first Disney Resort we stayed at so it's our favorite of the deluxes. We can stay there with DVC now too, so that makes it extra nice.