Discussion in 'Restaurants, Dining, Dining Plans' started by goofygal, Oct 14, 2008.
I think they're both kinda expensive so we'll probably only do one, which one would you recommend?
I`ve never had dinner at Shula`s so I can`t offer any views here but I would certainly recommend the YSH. The service and the location of the place, by the boardwalk, is perfect and an ideal location if you want to view Illuminations either before or after dinner.
I can only agree with Slowhand. IMHO Yachtsman is the best restaurant on Disney (although never tried V&A). I love the relaxing but professional service, I love the steaks and the layout of the tables, but more than anything I love the rolls and roasted garlic that comes round before you even start on the meal 015:
hmmm hmmm hmmmm ARgh I dont know useful huh?
There's a certain something to both places, a good upmarket feel.
Shulas is very dark to the point where last time they had to use a flashlight so we could read the menu on the football. Service wise they have that unbelievably good style where your water is constantly refilled and you dont even notice. The food has always been completely spot on although the portions tend to be too large for my personal liking. We ordered a dessert there once and it would have been enough for six people never mind two
YSH is a bit more disney in my opinion. It's excellent although there are a couple of less good servers again in my opinion. We've had 75% fantastic meals with fantastic servers and 25% less good meals and less good servers. They also keep ditching the things we like they've removed my bourbon steak
Which would I go for if I could only do one.. hmmmm. There's more choice at YSH and when it's good its really excellent so I guess I'd go for that unless someone in the party is really into american football or truly huge steaks in which case shulas will have the edge
Separate names with a comma.